I'm an unabashed fan of yuri anime and manga. I'm also an unabashed fan of
Maria Watches Over Us (Marimite), that seminal light-novel/anime which
restarted the yuri boom and also helped to define some of its current visual/plot conventions. "
Yuri is my Job" Volume 1 (
Kodansha Comics) sounded like a fun take on the genre. But what sounded like a great idea, was actually quite disappointing in its
execution.
"Yuri is my Job" is a comedy yuri manga about a first-year high-school
girl who gets roped into working as a waitress in a cafe. What makes this cafe
unique is that it is modeled on an all-girls school, similar to those in Marimite
(which of course was based on the historical Catholic schools of a century ago
in Japan as well as the types of ultra-close relationships between girls in those schools that was seen as natural before becoming adults: see
here and
here). In this cafe, the girls act the part of pure maidens, slowly forming
deep bonds with each other, and maybe choosing a special girl to be their
"schwestern" (German for sister and a classic play on "soeur" from
Marimite). The whole act is done for the adoring patrons, most of whom seem to
be young men.
Our lead character is Hime. Her goal in life is to be
married to a rich man and she will do everything she can to be so lovely that
no one could possibly say no. She never intended to work a day in her life. When she gets stuck working at the cafe, she
meets a tall, dark haired young woman named Ayanokouji (reminiscent of the classic older, perfectly proper, student). Hime is struck by this
woman and wants her approval as part of her overall quest to ensure everyone loves her. But Ayanokouji's personality is not at all the lovely
school maiden, but instead, is pissed that Hime is there at all. Despite all the Hime does to be likable, Ayanokouji seems unmoved, causing Hime much distress.
Hime's friend in school, Kanoko, gets worried about Hime, tracks her down, and gets brought into the cafe herself. We get hints that
Kanoko is actually obsessed with Hime. She also is quite aware that Hime is an
empty shell, just pretending to be lovely to attract her eventual husband. Hime, too, is pretty open (to herself anyway) about the fact that she has nothing other than her likability going for her. What she looks for in others is being liked, not anything in the least reciprocal. However, in an extra at the end, there is a brief exchange where Hime does seem concerned that Kanoko is doing something just for Hime's sake, and it's the first real moment where we see Hime care about anyone other than herself.
The volume focuses on Hime's desire to have Ayanokouji like
her (simply to prove that Hime is likeable) and Hime's rough introduction to
the rules of the cafe. We get the sense that Hime may eventually go beyond
wanting Ayanokouji to like her due to her fake traits, and actually like the
real Hime (or maybe this is wishful thinking on my part for some real plot and motivations). We also clearly get the sense that Kanoko likes Hime as more than a
friend. However, Ayanokouji reveals a further complication in this at the end
of the volume.
All that said, despite being billed as a romantic dramedy (on the back cover) this is a straight up comedy yuri as best I can tell. It seems to some
degree like its purpose is to have fun with the tropes of the genre. However,
it doesn't do so with the heart of a true fan. One gets the sense that someone
described yuri in a paragraph to the creator and the creator generated this story
based on that summary of the genre. I don't feel that this person loves yuri and wanted to satirize
it out of love. In fact, the entire thing seems like a commercially created
endeavor and not an honest work of art.
And for a comedy, it isn't actually very funny. The satire isn't rich or deep
enough for true fans, nor is it biting and scathing enough to be a counter-commentary. There is nothing but superficial elements of yuri
presented to signal the genre but not to actually dive into its nuances or
intricacies. Hime is a completely superficial character that is given no real
motivation for her ways and we spend no significant time with her outside of the cafe. Why should we bother to root for her or any of the
others? The writing is overall spastic and unclear throughout. The art is very typical and
uninspiring.
So maybe Hime will fall in love with Ayanokouji, maybe Ayanokouji will eventually overcome her dislike of Hime and reciprocate. Maybe Kanoko
will get hurt. Maybe Hime will realize how wonderful Kanoko is. But who cares?
The satire is surface level, the comedy is bland and perfunctory, the
characters are wooden and 2-dimensional, the writing is poor, the art forgettable, no real emotions are evoked, and the whole look of the book smacks
of something put together to pander to the audience. But I'm not even sure which audience that would be.
This isn't a work for true fans of yuri. I love the idea of
a yuri satire, but that satire should be targeted towards those who love yuri
the most and thus should be rich with details and unexpected ways of exploring
the tropes. OR, it should be a satire in criticism of the genre as a way of exploring problematic aspects within the genre. BUT instead, this is just a maid cafe set in a "yuri" world for the
sake of maybe eventually showing some girls kiss. It isn't funny, it isn't
romantic, it isn't heart-rending, it isn't much of anything. This gets a 5/10
from me and I won't be rushing to buy volume 2 any time soon.
By way of getting another opinion on this, here's Erika's review from
Okazu. Apparently things get slightly better in later volumes. I still might pass though.
✩🚺
